Best Cruelty-Free Eye Cream: 7 Products Reviewed


To help you with this, we have compiled a list of the best cruelty-free eye cream that are not tested on animals, so you can put on your make-up with a clear conscience.

It is vital that consumers are not duped or harmed by companies that opt for these archaic practices. Peta’s animal cruelty-free labeling means a company or brand is prohibited from testing animals for any of its ingredients, including its supply chain, recipes and finished products, said Dr. Julia Baines, science policy adviser at PETA.

Brands such as The Body Shop and Lush market themselves as “cruelty-free,” and we know their approach is ethical. Animal testing was banned in the UK in 1998 for cosmetics companies, but it is difficult for the global companies that produce to know for sure.

California, Illinois, Nevada, Australia, Colombia, Guatemala, New Zealand, South Korea, Taiwan, Turkey and several Brazilian states have passed laws banning or restricting cosmetic animal testing. India, Norway, Iceland and Switzerland have passed similar laws. Cosmetic companies in the United States that carry out animal experiments will not be able to sell their products in those countries unless they change their practices.

Leaping Bunny is the gold standard for cruelty-free eye cream and beauty products in the US and Cruelty Free International in other countries, but not all cruelty-free products are registered with them. PETA is the best known organization for certifying animal cruelty-free and vegan cosmetic brands.

Top 7 Best Cruelty-Free Eye Cream Reviews

 Baebody Eye GelEye Gel$$4.6
 LilyAna Naturals Eye CreamEye Cream$$4.5
 Pure Biology Total Eye CreamEye Cream$$4.3
 Mad Hippie Eye CreamEye Cream$$$4.4
 Honest Beauty Depuff Eye GelEye Gel$$4.6
 Nourish Organic Eye CreamEye Cream$4.3
 TULA Skin Care Eye BalmEye Balm$$4.4

Best Cruelty-Free Eye Cream Reviews

1. Baebody Eye Gel

Our Best Choice for Cruelty-Free Eye Cream!

best cruelty-free eye cream

Bertha Davis Review on Baebody Eye Gel

This eye gel moisturizes the eyes and applies smoothly and rapidly. I bought it to deal with dark circles under my eyes, little white dots under my eyes, redness, and color correction. I’ll go over each targeted objective in detail below.

best cruelty-free eye cream

As part of a layered skin care routine, I use this gel twice a day, morning and night.  Same measures at night, but instead of sunscreen, apply a sleep cream mask and a lip sleeping mask.I use a micellar water cleanser first, followed by a foaming cream rice water cleanse.

Dark Circles Problem

A 40% boost, making you appear more awake and plumping your eyes to some extent. I didn’t see a significant difference. It was possible to significantly increase the under-eye darkness by first applying a vitamin K serum.

White Dots Problem

This was the main problem, and it made no difference. Some people have correctable spots under their eyes, which are clogged pores. In my case, they are detected under the skin, and the only way to fully eliminate them will be to use fillers or fat grafting. This is what my dermatologist told me. If you have white dots that can be removed with professional help, use a BHA to deep clean your pores and battle those pesky white dots.

Redness Problem

This eye cream has a good amount of brightening impact and wakes up the pupils. However, it does not remove any redness caused by capillaries or damaged blood vessels. The form of correction necessitates the use of vitamin K.

Color correction: I had some sun damage remnants that I was trying to get rid of, and I was. This provided some benefit, but not a significant one. Over the course of 90 days, I believe you’ll see more dramatic results. However, if you only have minor damage and have substantially lightened it, as I have, you’ll definitely need more tailored treatments, such as microderm, laser, or in-office specialist treatments. The spots are too small to see and will most likely fade within the next few months. This can greatly boost the visibility of dark spots if you are first trying to erase them and they are very far away.

My overall impression is that, while this fantastic cruelty-free eye cream is not a magic panacea, it does provide some benefit and, over time, can produce more dramatic results. When used in conjunction with targeted treatments, this eye gel is more effective, and it also works well with other skin care products.

Store the eye gel in the fridge for a more relaxing and de-puffing effect. Many serums benefit from being kept cold because it extends their shelf life, provides a soothing sensation, and reduces puffiness. For those who are serious about their skin care, a cosmetics refrigerator is highly recommended.

2. LilyAna Naturals Eye Cream

best cruelty-free eye cream

Tara Fowler Review on LilyAna Naturals Eye Cream

I’m an oily mess in the summers and have to look for products to keep my pores contained, but as soon as fall arrives and the winter sets in, my skin becomes incredibly dry. There are a lot of dry spots. Especially around my eyes.

best cruelty-free eye cream

I purchased this product solely for this reason, but as my skin became even more dry, I decided to give it a try all over. This is how I like it. It moisturizes my face, prevents dry spots, and doesn’t leave my skin looking “cakey” or oily under makeup. When I add it before primer, it actually makes it look cleaner.

I wash my face and apply a pump under my eyes, patting it in with my fingers and making sure to concentrate on this place first. Then I add another pump and begin patting and upward rubbing with my neck as my starting point.

What a fantastic product! I’m always amazed by how much it improved the lines and wrinkles around my eyes. I apply it twice a day and cover my whole face and neck with it. My skin is so delicate, and the lines on my face are fading.

If you’re on the fence about getting it, go ahead and buy this cruelty-free eye cream. With the price point, you can’t go wrong. And the packaging is stunning in and of itself.

This family-owned business reached out to see how I liked it shortly after receiving it, which I thought was fantastic.

3. Pure Biology Total Eye Cream

best cruelty-free eye cream

Josephine Rowley Review on Pure Biology Total Eye Cream

I have to admit that the findings I’ve seen so far have blown me away. When I first started using it, I noticed that my fine lines had greatly decreased.

best cruelty-free eye cream

After about the fourth or fifth day, I began to notice a difference, which is odd. As far as I can tell, my under eyes aren’t any brighter. This is a light, creamy formula that absorbs quickly into my skin without leaving any sticky or oily residue, and it also works well under makeup.

I’ve been using this cream for a little over three weeks and apply it twice daily. I cleanse, exfoliate, and toner my face before applying Total Eye. I then apply the eye cream to my fingers and gently spread the cream around my eyes.

In my opinion, This bottle’s pump dispenser give a little bit too much the amount I needed, which appears to be a common problem for all of this company’s items!

Apart from that, I’m pleased with my results so far; I like the light, smooth texture of the eye cream, and it fits well under my makeup, so I’ll keep using it. I would certainly recommend this cruelty-free eye cream to anyone looking for an inexpensive eye cream; it’s well worth a try!

4. Mad Hippie Eye Cream

best cruelty-free eye cream

Mary Swider Review on Mad Hippie Eye Cream

For my skin, I use a variety of items. I’m not going to let myself get away with being frugal in that sector. These aren’t too costly, but the bottle is ridiculously small. That said, there’s a whole lot of magic in that tiny glass!

This stuff is incredible! Insomnia, sun, pregnancy, and genetics have all contributed to my dark circles under my eyes. People also comment about how tired I seem because of the hyperpigmentation under my eyes. People don’t know how offensive it is to say to anyone, and it makes me uncomfortable.

I began this in the hopes of growing my hyperpigmentation over time. Yes, it has! I’ve been using it for about four or five weeks now, and my skin has become more refined and even. I’m completely smitten with this stuff. It greatly reduces puffiness under my eyes. The pump on the bottle helps me to place a little amount directly on the areas I want to reach.

A little makes a big difference

Like how surprised I was by how long the first bottle lasted. I’ve purchased twice and will repeat to do so. It took a few weeks for me to note any noticeable glow effect around my eyes or less apparent wrinkles.

I don’t have crow’s feet yet (lucky), but it seems to have prevented the line in my forehead from wearing a permanent expression of worry or concentration for the past 20 years. Chronic anxiety does, in fact, leave lines on your forehead!

This line also has a vitamin C serum that I really like. This has also made a significant difference. Is it just me, or does my skin seem to be soft? I honestly have no idea. Much improved over the previous situation.

In any case, I adore this eye cream. Before I started using these, I had never received any compliments on my skin. I’ve had big pores, combination skin, and a lot of blackheads, among other things. Things have vastly changed since then. While it hasn’t completely vanished, I don’t hold out much hope for a miracle.

5. Honest Beauty Depuff Eye Gel

best cruelty-free eye cream

Jessica McCarthy Review on Honest Beauty Depuff Eye Gel

The eye cream is effective and contains only natural ingredients! This is applied with the applicator, which helps the eye cream to be applied cold. That aspect appeals to me, and the creamy eye cream itself applies smoothly and feels great when applied cold. After using this product, my eyes appear moisturized and slightly less puffy, but they are not dry.

I’m guilty of not having enough sleep on a regular basis, which results in puffy eyes. For a few weeks, I’ve been consistently using the gel twice a day, and it has improved the appearance of my skin.

This Honest Beauty eye cream performs well if the eyes are puffy from not having enough sleep. The applicator makes it slide on smoothly, and it feels soft and cool under your eyes. It absorbs quickly and leaves the eye area feeling moisturised. This is a perfect option if you need a moisturizing eye cream to help you recover from a sleepless night.

The gel is packaged in a small tube with a self-administering tip. The tip making it easy to dispense a tiny amount and spread it out with my finger.

There is no unpleasant odor, and the Honest Beauty business does an excellent job by using sterile ingredients and recyclable packaging. The price is fair, and the consistency is excellent, and my eyes are less puffy and feel better in the morning.

I’ve tried other items that claim to reduce puffiness under the eyes, and most of them don’t work. I was delighted to discover that cruelty-free eye cream from Honest Beauty made a difference.

I’m pleased with the outcome will definitely use it every day for much better result.

6. Nourish Organic Eye Cream

best cruelty-free eye cream

Denise Beckley Review on Nourish Organic Eye Cream

This is a good ‘middle ground’ eye cream, which means it’s good in terms of price. Don’t expect miracles because it’s not top-of-the-line, but it’s one of my favorite budget-friendly eye creams. I have very dry skin, and this is so calming and hydrating that it keeps me hydrated for the majority of the day. It does leave a glow for around an hour after application, but it has never changed the appearance of my makeup.

It’s awesome, and I use it twice a day. It holds my wrinkles at bay. Stuff to be concerned about when you get older. It’s relaxing and enjoyable to wear. A flat metal circle serves as the top, which should be smoothed over your eyes. However, I’ve discovered that using my finger is the most effective. When I use the applicator, I use a LOT more liquid than I need.

After two months, the puffiness under the eyes has significantly decreased. The product has a pleasant scent and is simple to apply. When I use it, I note a difference in the color and texture underneath my eyes.

When I run out, I can certainly repurchase. What I like most about it is how natural it is. What’s more, no animal testing!  It’s perfect. Overall, I would suggest it.

7. TULA Skin Care Eye Balm

Ann McDonald Review on TULA Skin Care Eye Balm

I noticed a faint glow around my friend’s eyes; she appeared to be well rested, and she informed me about this product. I thought it was a little pricey at first, but I wanted to give it a shot. Although it is not as moisturising as I had hoped, I have used it as a pick-me-up during the day.

After my regular moisturiser, I add this. Only a single swipe under each eye. A cooling feeling will occur. Since it’s tinted with a soft highlighter, it’ll make you look rested and revitalised. You can even use it on top of your base. Simply tap it in with your finger and you are good to go.

It conceals my tired eyes and leaves a lovely sheen. I don’t think I’d wear it over mascara, because who wears makeup under a mask these days? This girl is not one of them. When I run out, I will certainly purchase again. That shouldn’t be for a while because you won’t be using much. It’s also totally greasy-free.

Some reviews reported a strange odour (like corn chips); at first, I didn’t notice any odour, but after a month of use, I do detect the distinct corn chip odour. That isn’t going to deter me from using it.

Overall, a fantastic cruelty-free eye cream!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *